This is a clean Denny Triangle comparison because both buildings are high-rises, both are 41 stories, both publish a Walk Score of 98, and both have verified building data in the registry. The first split is age and scale: Insignia Towers was built in 2015 with 698 residences, while Spire was built in 2021 with 343 residences.
The amenity lists also overlap without being identical. Insignia Towers lists indoor pool, dog park, sky lounge, concierge, and sauna. Spire lists pool, gym, concierge, and sky lounge. Those are useful starting points, but the real decision still needs the current HOA budget, reserve study, meeting minutes, insurance information, parking details, and rules for the specific unit.
I would not choose between these buildings from the headline facts alone. Put the exact units side by side on monthly cost, floor, exposure, parking, reserves, rental policy, pet policy, and current building documents. The better choice is the unit and HOA position that underwrites cleanly, not just the newer tower or the larger tower.